Legacy Pie Co. isn’t just a pie shop; it's a slice of fourth-generation family legacy on Tennyson Street, where Elias and Rachel Lehnert are turning family recipes into must-try modern treats.
Step up your pie game with their menu that slays with both sweet classics like cherry and edgy savory options like buffalo chicken. Because why settle for ordinary?
All about that authentic taste? Legacy Pie Co. is here with locally sourced ingredients that make each pie feel like a homemade piece of heaven.
Pair your pie with perfection. Whether it’s coffee from their full espresso bar or ciders, they’ve got your back in making every bite a major moment.
It’s not just about the food—it’s about the vibes. Legacy Pie Co. is the ultimate community hotspot on Tennyson, turning pie eating into a full-on social affair.
Take & Bake pies available so you can keep the pie party going at home. Store in your Freezer and bake at your convenience!
Top Picks
🍏 APPLE BOURBON CARAMEL
brown sugar apples topped w bourbon caramel oat topping
🍒 TART CHERRY
tart Montmorency cherries in signature all-butter crust
🥧 CLASSIC CHICKEN POT PIE
classic chicken pot pie w peas, carrots, onions, celery + a cream-based sauce
🍰 KEY LIME PIE
tart + tangy key lime pie in a graham cracker crust + topped w fresh whipped cream (gluten-free)
🫐 MIXED BERRY
strawberry, blackberry, blueberry, + raspberry all packed together in their classic all-butter crust
Parking
Street parking only, the parking spots are typically 2 to 3 hours. If you can't find a spot on Tennyson, we recommend looking for parking on Stuart Street.
Photos
FAQs
What is Offline?
Offline is a restaurant subscription app that gets you to try amazing local spots + covers part of the check.
How does it work?
1. Open our app to see available restaurants in your city.
2. Visit any available restaurant.
3. Show your server the Offer as you redeem for $10-50+ off your bill.
Do I need to join Offline to use this discount?
Yes, you can join Offline at an exclusive price to try this restaurant + access 500+ others.
Do I need to spend a minimum amount to get this discount?
Yes. Your total before tax and tip has to meet or exceed the offer amount, or the minimum if the restaurant sets one. For example, with $20 to spend, a bill of $20 or more before tax and tip qualifies.
Please tip generously. Let's support local restaurants together.
